History

Monarch butterflies, originally from the Americas, now flutter across the globe, reaching Europe, Africa, and Australia. In North America, two migratory groups exist: one heads to Mexico for winter, while the other settles along California’s coast. The vibrant San Francisco Bay Area, with its Mediterranean climate, hosts several of these winter retreats. Surveys of monarchs and milkweeds here reveal fascinating insights into urban winter-breeding populations. This research shines a light on the vital role urban spaces play in conservation, even as they face challenges like disease and predation. It underscores how cities can nurture monarchs and pollinators, all while acknowledging the essential worth of natural habitats.

Urban environments can be lively centers for various species, especially pollinators, but it’s unclear if they provide quality habitats or act as traps. Recently, a nonmigratory, winter-breeding group of monarch butterflies has been identified in Northern California’s urban gardens. Opinions differ on whether these urban populations help or harm the migratory monarchs. Research by E. Erickson, C. B. Schultz, and E. Crone from UC Davis involved monthly surveys of monarchs and milkweeds in California’s East Bay. Their two-year study showed that winter-breeding monarchs aren’t strongly supported by the migratory population. Monarch numbers were highest in summer, linked to abundant milkweed, which was unexpected during migration. They identified two types of monarchs: migratory and non-migratory. Both types used all kinds of milkweed. Despite heavy parasite loads, these increased during fall migration, contradicting predictions, and were found on all milkweed types. This challenges the idea that non-native species are more prone to parasites. Summer showed a lower larva-to-egg ratio, likely due to predation by urban species like wasps, but population growth wasn’t stopped. These trends differ from studies on eastern North American monarchs, emphasizing the need to understand how species thrive in urban settings and the unique conservation role of urban communities. Findings showed population growth wasn’t aligned with migration patterns, indicating urban gardens’ unique conservation potential. source

All Milkweed is GOOD

Conclusion

Nonetheless, the tentative conclusion by the research team at UC Davis is threefold: (1) Populations of winter-breeding monarchs in urban gardens in the East Bay are unlikely to be an ecological trap for migratory monarchs. (2) Populations of monarchs in large urban areas promote interest in all monarchs, even in cities where urban populations are winter-breeding and nonmigratory. However, (3) Creating gardens for these winter-breeding populations does not replace the conservation of migratory monarchs. The phenomenon of monarch migration is an important conservation target that is neither replaced nor—in our study region—harmed by winter-breeding monarchs in urban gardens.

Planting milkweed in your garden is a simple yet powerful way to contribute to the conservation of monarch butterflies. By providing a habitat rich in native and non-native milkweed species, you can support both the migratory and winter-breeding populations. This diversity of milkweed not only serves as a breeding ground but also offers essential nectar resources for a variety of pollinators. Whether you have a large garden or a small balcony, every plant counts towards creating a network of urban sanctuaries. Together, we can foster a thriving environment that supports these iconic butterflies and the broader ecosystem. So, let’s roll up our sleeves, get our hands in the soil, and make a meaningful impact on monarch conservation. Visit Wings of Change to explore the range of plants and seeds that can transform your space into a haven for monarchs and other pollinators. Your garden can be a beacon of hope for these beautiful creatures, ensuring they continue to grace our skies for generations to come.

BE the change… Become a member!